Beauty Without Cruelty Extra Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

love it
From Shana Cobin of Foster, Rhode Island on 12/8/2015.

It's very gentle and works great!

OK if desperate
From Sarah of Brooklyn, New York on 4/24/2008.

This stuff is just okay. It gets the job done but it leaves your eyes dry and in slight pain. The Earth Science eye makeup remover (a gel) is much, much better.

It's OK but I miss Paul Pender's
From Anonymous of Chicago, Illinois on 1/28/2008.

This stuff works ok, but it's too fluid, too easy to spill, and it stings my eyes.
I remember the Paul Pender's makeup remover fondly. What happened, Did PP's reformulate to non-vegan?

good product, gentle
From Anonymous of Las Vegas, Nevada on 1/17/2008.

However, I personally like a cream based makeup remover over the liquid based (as this one is). It lasts a long time, too.

waterproof makeup?
From Melissa Desjardins of Rawdon, Quebec on 8/3/2007.

I ordered this product because I purchased a Splash proof mascara and did not have a proper eye makeup removal product. Unfortunately, this product wasn't strong enough to remove the mascara, so I ended up wearing my running mascara for 2 days. For eye shadows, normal Mascara, I find that this product is good.