Thumbs Up! Crispy Peanut Butter Candy Bar by Go Max Go Foods

Tastes exactly like its nonvegan counterpart
From Delia Ayala of San Francisco, California on 3/18/2021.

These taste exactly how I remember a butterfinger did. The chocolate tastes like milk, not dark, and the filling is perfect. Only complaint is that these are on the smaller side, like only a little bigger than what you'd imagine a fun size candy being. Nevertheless, I say it's worth ordering if you have the money and miss them.

Sticky Vegan Treat
From Emily of Depew, New York on 6/17/2020.

I love these little bars. The peanut butter inside is sticky just like the real deal, and is packed with flavor. It is not as flaky as a fresh Butterfinger, but it still replicates the flavor well. The chocolate pairs well, and is not too dark. Defiantly would recommend!!

Decent
From Anna Lapchenko of Everett, Washington on 6/5/2020.

I loved Butterfingers and based on the reviews, I was really excited. Unfortunately, it wasn't all the great. The chocolate was delicious but the filling could use some work. Butterfingers are known for their buttery, flakey yet flavorful. The filling here was a bit on the drier side and not as peanut buttery as I would've hoped. I may buy this again but it's not going to be a staple in my pantry.

BETTER THAN BUTTERFINGER
From Robyn of New City, New York on 1/9/2020.

Before going vegan, Butterfinger was my favorite candy bar. I was fine with having to give it up obviously, but when I tasted Thumbs Up for the first time, I almost cried at how GOOD IT IS!! Go Max Go is amazing. I've tried all of their candy bars at this point and they are all just as good - if not better - than the "real thing." Thumbs Up is SERIOUSLY TWO THUMBS UP!! My FAVORITE

two thumbs up
From Lauren Andalora of Salt Lake City, Utah on 11/5/2018.

I bought $60 worth of chocolate for my boyfriend's birthday. This was one of his favorites. Just like a butterfinger but better.