Thumbs Up! Crispy Peanut Butter Candy Bar by Go Max Go Foods

Tastes exactly like its nonvegan counterpart
From Delia Ayala of San Francisco, California on 3/18/2021.

These taste exactly how I remember a butterfinger did. The chocolate tastes like milk, not dark, and the filling is perfect. Only complaint is that these are on the smaller side, like only a little bigger than what you'd imagine a fun size candy being. Nevertheless, I say it's worth ordering if you have the money and miss them.

Sticky Vegan Treat
From Emily of Depew, New York on 6/17/2020.

I love these little bars. The peanut butter inside is sticky just like the real deal, and is packed with flavor. It is not as flaky as a fresh Butterfinger, but it still replicates the flavor well. The chocolate pairs well, and is not too dark. Defiantly would recommend!!

Decent
From Anna Lapchenko of Everett, Washington on 6/5/2020.

I loved Butterfingers and based on the reviews, I was really excited. Unfortunately, it wasn't all the great. The chocolate was delicious but the filling could use some work. Butterfingers are known for their buttery, flakey yet flavorful. The filling here was a bit on the drier side and not as peanut buttery as I would've hoped. I may buy this again but it's not going to be a staple in my pantry.

BETTER THAN BUTTERFINGER
From Robyn of New City, New York on 1/9/2020.

Before going vegan, Butterfinger was my favorite candy bar. I was fine with having to give it up obviously, but when I tasted Thumbs Up for the first time, I almost cried at how GOOD IT IS!! Go Max Go is amazing. I've tried all of their candy bars at this point and they are all just as good - if not better - than the "real thing." Thumbs Up is SERIOUSLY TWO THUMBS UP!! My FAVORITE

two thumbs up
From Lauren Andalora of Salt Lake City, Utah on 11/5/2018.

I bought $60 worth of chocolate for my boyfriend's birthday. This was one of his favorites. Just like a butterfinger but better.

Tiny but good
From Anonymous of Springfield, Missouri on 7/29/2018.

I haven't had a Butterfinger in 12 years but this is just like I remember it. Even the way in gets stuck in your teeth. But it's 1/4 the size

So amazing!
From Sarah of Staten Island, New York on 3/24/2017.

I don't eat a ton of sweets, but I love these candy bars and have at least one a month. They are the perfect balance of chocolate, crunchy, and sweet!

I'm happy with it
From RCass of Chicago, Illinois on 4/15/2016.

Having not had chocolate bars (well yummy ones) in such a long time - this is FANTASTIC. I can see it being a little disappointing for some, it is kinda flaky and maybe not the taste you were looking for - but for me, I LOVED IT. It was exactly what I am looking for and cannot wait to order it again, yum yum yum!!!

UGGGH
From Lakecia McGraw of Huber Heights, Ohio on 3/10/2016.

I read the reviews and I could not wait until i tried this one but it was not what I was expecting. It leaves a very dissatisfying aftertaste and it's just really not that good to me.

BEST EVER
From Anonymous of Alexandria, Virginia on 10/21/2015.

Thumbs Up, Jokerz, and Cleos are the BEST EVER. No other vegan candy bar or candy bar for that matter comes close. I can't believe my local health food stores won't carry them. The stuff on the shelves are just awful. Thank you Go Max Go!!

The Best!!!
From Vegan Immortal of Chicago, Illinois on 4/8/2014.

These candy bars make my life better. I had not eaten a Butterfinger for probably 20 or 25 years. Now there is a vegan version and it is delicious! Wow!

Amazing!
From Kyle of Boston, Massachusetts on 3/19/2014.

Thumbs Up and Snap are the best vegan candy bars I've ever had.

Yes!! Heavenly!
From theen of Chicago, Illinois on 1/25/2014.

Delish! If you like a crunchy centre covered in chocolate (similar to the English 'Crunchie' bar [if I may make a comparison])then this is for you!!

SO GOOD! TOO SMALL! Need More!
From Brenda Marie of New York, New York on 7/24/2013.

THIS candy bar is AMAZING - I think I am in love. Tastes just like a Butterfinger. I am already addicted and thank goodness that they are not available near my home as we would then defninitely have some kind of problem.

My only complaint as I have tried the other Go Max Go vegan candy bars - is that this one - being the BEST one, by the way - is also the SMALLEST one.

I don't mind that the shape is not like the real one - but there is just one little log in the wrapper... If they put two in the package - woo hoo!!! I was tempted to take one star off my review for that fact - but seriously it is too yummy to do that!

rock my socks
From liz ranalli of palm beach gardens, Florida on 3/15/2013.

Everything Go Max Go Foods touches is amazing! This is just like a Butterfinger. Crunchy and flaky and tasty. I also love that they use rice milk chocolate and not dark. I love dark chocolate but it's great that it's a vegan friendly milk chocolate, it just makes the candy bars taste that much more like the original non-vegan version.

Awesome!
From Anonymous of Raleigh, North Carolina on 2/2/2013.

This candy bar is soooo good! My only problem is that it is too small :( I want more!

Pretty Similiar
From Robert Hall of Somewhere, Kentucky on 1/28/2013.

Yep, these are pretty similiar. Not perfect, but will fill that craving if you have it. Yum. Though pretty small.

Exactly like a Butterfinger
From Billy of Coral Springs, Florida on 1/23/2013.

This tastes EXACTLY like a Butterfinger! I had heard the rumors but didn't believe them until I tried one. If you loved Butterfingers, you'll love these. They nailed the taste and consistency.

Everything You're Hoping It Will BE
From Angela of Austin, Texas on 1/17/2013.

I have tried almost all of these Go Max Go candy bars by now. Jokerz, Mahalo, Cleo's, etc. They're all really good on their own, but none of them taste EXACTLY like the original. None, that is, until the Thumbs Up! bar came along. If you put a blind fold on me and fed me a bite of this bar, I wouldn't say "hmm.. tastes kinda like a Butterfinger, but not quite." I would think "This is definitely a Butterfinger." The shape is a little different; the taste is so similar. If you miss Butterfingers, you won't be disappointed. I immediately started daydreaming about all the things I could do with this. Sprinkle into ice cream, for example. :)

Amazingly perfect!
From Anonymous of Fredericksburg, Virginia on 1/1/2013.

I knew this would be the best part of my Christmas stocking - thank you, Santa! Yet another pre-vegan favorite that has been veganized perfectly! My favorite candy bar of all time - worth the cost!

Delish!
From Melissa of Westborough, Massachusetts on 12/19/2012.

It's been years since I have a Butterfinger, but this is just like how I remember it!

They did it again!
From Naomi of Burlington, Vermont on 12/15/2012.

These are AMAZING!!! Highly Recommend!

Amazing!
From Anonymous of Burlington, Vermont on 12/14/2012.

This is so amazing! I just ordered one to try and I wish I ordered more. It tastes like a butterfinger but better. Crunchy, Crispy, Chocolatey. Without nasty ingredients. Recommended for anyone needing the vegan alternative. Heaven!